Johnny Depp – James "Whitey" Bulger
Joel Edgerton – John Connolly (FBI-handler)
Benedict Cumberbatch – William "Billy" Bulger (MA Senatsvoorzitter)
Dakota Johnson – Lindsey Cyr (Whitey's partner)
Kevin Bacon – Charles McGuire (FBI)
Peter Sarsgaard – Brian Halloran (informer)
Corey Stoll – Robert Fitzpatrick (FBI)
Jesse Plemons – Kevin Weeks (handlanger)
Rory Cochrane – Stephen Flemmi
David Harbour – John Morris (FBI)
Geregisseerd door Scott Cooper; gebaseerd op Alliance of Evil / Black Mass boeken.